Firm embryo transfer catheters for assisted reproduction: A systematic review and meta-analysis using direct and adjusted indirect comparisons

A systematic review of published evidence on firm embryo transfer catheters is presented. Extensive searches were conducted for full-text manuscripts, abstracts, ongoing and unpublished trials. Direct and adjusted indirect comparisons were undertaken, where appropriate. Twenty-six randomized controlled trials comparing embryo transfer catheters were identified. Only two trials (314 transfers) compared different firm embryo catheters. Using direct comparison, both the Tom Cat and Tefcat catheters demonstrated statistically significant increased chances of clinical pregnancy compared with the Tight Difficult Transfer (TDT) catheter (P = 0.007; OR = 3.67, 95% CI = 1.48-9.10 and P < 0.0001; OR = 4.71, 95% Cl = 2.34-9.48 respectively). The implantation rates were also higher with the Tom Cat and Tefcat catheters than the TDT catheter (P = 0.005; OR = 3.67,95% CI = 1.48-9.10 and P < 0.00001; OR = 4.29,95% CI = 2.45-7.50 respectively). Using adjusted indirect comparison, Tom Cat and Tefcat catheters were compared, and shown to have similar pregnancy and implantation rates (OR = 0.99; 95% CI = -0.87-1.79 and OR = 0.86; 95% Cl = -0.77-1.35). In conclusion, both Tom Cat and Tefcat catheters give better outcomes than the TDT catheter, but are similar to each other.