Skip to content
Home
About Us
Resources
Profiles Metrics
Authors Directory
Institutions Directory
Top Authors
Top Institutions
Top Sponsors
AI Digest
Contact Us
Menu
Home
About Us
Resources
Profiles Metrics
Authors Directory
Institutions Directory
Top Authors
Top Institutions
Top Sponsors
AI Digest
Contact Us
Home
About Us
Resources
Profiles Metrics
Authors Directory
Institutions Directory
Top Authors
Top Institutions
Top Sponsors
AI Digest
Contact Us
Menu
Home
About Us
Resources
Profiles Metrics
Authors Directory
Institutions Directory
Top Authors
Top Institutions
Top Sponsors
AI Digest
Contact Us
Publication Details
AFRICAN RESEARCH NEXUS
SHINING A SPOTLIGHT ON AFRICAN RESEARCH
medicine
Reproducibility in the absence of selective reporting: An illustration from large-scale brain asymmetry research
Human Brain Mapping, Volume 43, No. 1, Year 2022
Notification
URL copied to clipboard!
Description
The problem of poor reproducibility of scientific findings has received much attention over recent years, in a variety of fields including psychology and neuroscience. The problem has been partly attributed to publication bias and unwanted practices such as p-hacking. Low statistical power in individual studies is also understood to be an important factor. In a recent multisite collaborative study, we mapped brain anatomical left–right asymmetries for regional measures of surface area and cortical thickness, in 99 MRI datasets from around the world, for a total of over 17,000 participants. In the present study, we revisited these hemispheric effects from the perspective of reproducibility. Within each dataset, we considered that an effect had been reproduced when it matched the meta-analytic effect from the 98 other datasets, in terms of effect direction and significance threshold. In this sense, the results within each dataset were viewed as coming from separate studies in an “ideal publishing environment,” that is, free from selective reporting and p hacking. We found an average reproducibility rate of 63.2% (SD = 22.9%, min = 22.2%, max = 97.0%). As expected, reproducibility was higher for larger effects and in larger datasets. Reproducibility was not obviously related to the age of participants, scanner field strength, FreeSurfer software version, cortical regional measurement reliability, or regional size. These findings constitute an empirical illustration of reproducibility in the absence of publication bias or p hacking, when assessing realistic biological effects in heterogeneous neuroscience data, and given typically-used sample sizes. © 2020 The Authors. Human Brain Mapping published by Wiley Periodicals LLC.
Authors & Co-Authors
Kong, Xiangzhen
Netherlands, Nijmegen
Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics
China, Hangzhou
Zhejiang University
Francks, Clyde
Netherlands, Nijmegen
Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics
Netherlands, Nijmegen
Radboud Universiteit
Mathias, Samuel R.
Unknown Affiliation
Guadalupe, Tulio M.
Unknown Affiliation
Abé, Christoph
Unknown Affiliation
Agartz, Ingrid A.
Unknown Affiliation
Akudjedu, Theophilus N.
Unknown Affiliation
Aleman, André
Unknown Affiliation
Alhusaini, Saud
Unknown Affiliation
Allen, Nicholas B.
Unknown Affiliation
Ames, David J.
Unknown Affiliation
Andreassen, Ole Andreas
Unknown Affiliation
Vásquez, Alejandro Arias
Unknown Affiliation
Armstrong, Nicola J.
Unknown Affiliation
Asherson, Philip J.E.
Unknown Affiliation
Bergo, Felipe Paulo Guazzi
Unknown Affiliation
Bastin, Mark E.
Unknown Affiliation
Batalla, Albert
Unknown Affiliation
Bauer, Jochen
Unknown Affiliation
Baune, Bernhard T.
Unknown Affiliation
Baur-Streubel, Ramona
Unknown Affiliation
Biederman, Joseph B.
Unknown Affiliation
Blaine, Sara K.
Unknown Affiliation
Boedhoe, Premika S.W.
Unknown Affiliation
Bøen, Erlend
Unknown Affiliation
Bose, Anushree
Unknown Affiliation
Bralten, Janita B.
Unknown Affiliation
Brandeis, Daniel
Unknown Affiliation
Brem, Silvia
Unknown Affiliation
Brodaty, Henry
Unknown Affiliation
Yuksel, Dilara
Unknown Affiliation
Brooks, Samantha Jane
Unknown Affiliation
Buitelaar, Jan K.
Unknown Affiliation
Bürger, Christian
Unknown Affiliation
Bülow, Robin
Unknown Affiliation
Calhoun, Vince D.
Unknown Affiliation
Calvo, Anna
Unknown Affiliation
Canales-Rodríguez, Erick Jorge
Unknown Affiliation
Cannon, Dara M.
Unknown Affiliation
Caparelli, Elisabeth De Castro
Unknown Affiliation
Castellanos, Francisco Xavier
Unknown Affiliation
Cendes, Fernando
Unknown Affiliation
Chaim-Avancini, Tiffany Moukbel
Unknown Affiliation
Chantiluke, Kaylita C.
Unknown Affiliation
Chen, Qunlin
Unknown Affiliation
Chen, Xiayu
Unknown Affiliation
Cheng, Yuqi
Unknown Affiliation
Christakou, Anastasia K.
Unknown Affiliation
Clark, Vincent P.
Unknown Affiliation
Coghill, David R.
Unknown Affiliation
Connolly, Colm G.
Unknown Affiliation
Conzelmann, Annette
Unknown Affiliation
Córdova-Palomera, Aldo
Unknown Affiliation
Cousijn, Janna
Unknown Affiliation
Crow, Timothy John
Unknown Affiliation
Cubillo, Ana Isabel
Unknown Affiliation
Dannlowski, Udo
Unknown Affiliation
de Bruttopilo, Sara Ambrosino
Unknown Affiliation
de Zeeuw, Patrick
Unknown Affiliation
Deary, Ian J.
Unknown Affiliation
Demeter, Damion V.
Unknown Affiliation
Di Martino, Adriana
Unknown Affiliation
Dickie, Erin W.
Unknown Affiliation
Dietsche, Bruno
Unknown Affiliation
Doan, Nhat Trung
Unknown Affiliation
Doherty, Colin P.
Unknown Affiliation
Doyle, Alysa E.
Unknown Affiliation
Durston, Sarah
Unknown Affiliation
Earl, Eric A.
Unknown Affiliation
Ehrlich, Stefan
Unknown Affiliation
Ekman, Carl Johan
Unknown Affiliation
Elvsåshagen, Torbjorn
Unknown Affiliation
Epstein, Jeffery N.
Unknown Affiliation
Fair, Damien A.
Unknown Affiliation
Faraone, Stephen V.
Unknown Affiliation
Fernández, Guillén
Unknown Affiliation
Flint, Claas
Unknown Affiliation
Filho, Geraldo Busatto
Unknown Affiliation
Förster, Katharina
Unknown Affiliation
Fouché, Jean Paul
Unknown Affiliation
Foxe, John John
Unknown Affiliation
Frodl, Thomas S.
Unknown Affiliation
Fuentes-Claramonte, Paola
Unknown Affiliation
Fullerton, Janice M.
Unknown Affiliation
Garavan, Hugh P.
Unknown Affiliation
Gotlib, Ian H.
Unknown Affiliation
Goudriaan, A. E.
Unknown Affiliation
Grabe, Hans Jörgen
Unknown Affiliation
Groenewold, Nynke A.
Unknown Affiliation
Grotegerd, Dominik
Unknown Affiliation
Gruber, Oliver
Unknown Affiliation
Gurholt, Tiril P.
Unknown Affiliation
Haavik, Jan
Unknown Affiliation
Hahn, Tim
Unknown Affiliation
Hansell, Narelle K.
Unknown Affiliation
Harris, Mathew A.
Unknown Affiliation
Hartman, Catharina Annette
Unknown Affiliation
Heslenfeld, Dirk J.
Unknown Affiliation
Hester, Robert L.
Unknown Affiliation
Hibar, Derrek Paul
Unknown Affiliation
Ho, Beng Choon
Unknown Affiliation
Ho, Tiffany C.
Unknown Affiliation
Hoekstra, Pieter J.
Unknown Affiliation
van Holst, Ruth J.
Unknown Affiliation
Hoogman, Martine
Unknown Affiliation
Howells, Fleur Margaret
Unknown Affiliation
Huyser, Chaim
Unknown Affiliation
Ingvar, Martin C.
Unknown Affiliation
James, Anthony C.
Unknown Affiliation
Jahanshad, Neda
Unknown Affiliation
Jernigan, Terry L.
Unknown Affiliation
Jönsson, Erik Gunnar
Unknown Affiliation
Kaleda, Vasilii G.
Unknown Affiliation
Keshavan, Matcheri S.
Unknown Affiliation
Kircher, Tilo T.J.
Unknown Affiliation
Korucuoglu, Ozlem
Unknown Affiliation
Krämer, Bernd K.
Unknown Affiliation
Krug, Axel
Unknown Affiliation
Kuntsi, Jonna
Unknown Affiliation
Kwon, Junsoo
Unknown Affiliation
Landén, Mikaél
Unknown Affiliation
Lázaro, María Luisa
Unknown Affiliation
Lebedeva, Irina S.
Unknown Affiliation
Lenroot, Rhoshel K.
Unknown Affiliation
Lesch, Klaus Peter
Unknown Affiliation
Lim, Kelvin O.
Unknown Affiliation
Lochner, Christine
Unknown Affiliation
London, Edythe D.
Unknown Affiliation
Lorenzetti, Valentina
Unknown Affiliation
Luciano, Michelle
Unknown Affiliation
Luijten, Maartje M.W.
Unknown Affiliation
Lundervold, Astri Johansen
Unknown Affiliation
MacKey, Scott
Unknown Affiliation
MacMaster, Frank P.
Unknown Affiliation
Maingault, Sophie
Unknown Affiliation
Malpas, Charles B.
Unknown Affiliation
Malt, Ulrik Fredrik
Unknown Affiliation
Mataix-Cols, David
Unknown Affiliation
Martín-Santos, Roció
Unknown Affiliation
Mayer, Andrew R.
Unknown Affiliation
Medland, Sarah E.
Unknown Affiliation
Mitchell, Philip B.
Unknown Affiliation
Mueller, Bryon A.
Unknown Affiliation
Muñoz Maniega, Susana
Unknown Affiliation
Mazoyer, Bernard M.
Unknown Affiliation
McDonald, Colm D.
Unknown Affiliation
McLellan, Quinn
Unknown Affiliation
McMahon, Katie L.
Unknown Affiliation
McPhilemy, Genevieve
Unknown Affiliation
Momenan, Reza
Unknown Affiliation
Morales, Angelica M.
Unknown Affiliation
Narayanaswamy, Janardhanan C.
Unknown Affiliation
Nerland, Stener
Unknown Affiliation
Nordvik, Jan Egil
Unknown Affiliation
Oosterlaan, Jaap
Unknown Affiliation
Oranje, Bob
Unknown Affiliation
Orr, Catherine A.
Unknown Affiliation
Overs, Bronwyn J.
Unknown Affiliation
Paulus, Martin P.
Unknown Affiliation
Pomarol-Clotet, Edith
Unknown Affiliation
Portella Moll, Maria J.
Unknown Affiliation
Qiu, Jiang
Unknown Affiliation
Radua, Joaquim
Unknown Affiliation
Ramos-Quiroga, J. Antoni
Unknown Affiliation
Reddy, Yemmigannur Chandrashekhar Janardhan
Unknown Affiliation
Reif, Andreas
Unknown Affiliation
Roberts, Gloria M.P.
Unknown Affiliation
Rosa, Pedro Gomes Penteado
Unknown Affiliation
Rubia, Katya K.
Unknown Affiliation
Sacchet, Matthew D.
Unknown Affiliation
Sachdev, Perminder S.
Unknown Affiliation
Salvador, Raymond
Unknown Affiliation
Schmaal, Lianne
Unknown Affiliation
Schulte-Rüther, Martin
Unknown Affiliation
Schweren, Lizanne Johanna Stephanie
Unknown Affiliation
Serpa, Mauricio Henriques
Unknown Affiliation
Shumskaya, Elena
Unknown Affiliation
Silk, Timothy J.
Unknown Affiliation
Simmons, Alan N.
Unknown Affiliation
Simulionyte, Egle
Unknown Affiliation
Sinha, Rajita
Unknown Affiliation
Sjoerds, Zsuzsika
Unknown Affiliation
Solowij, Nadia
Unknown Affiliation
Sponheim, Scott R.
Unknown Affiliation
Stein, Dan J.
Unknown Affiliation
Stein, Elliot A.
Unknown Affiliation
Strike, Lachlan T.
Unknown Affiliation
Sudre, Gustavo P.
Unknown Affiliation
Temmingh, Henk S.
Unknown Affiliation
Tomyshev, Alexander S.
Unknown Affiliation
Turner, Jessica A.
Unknown Affiliation
Uhlmann, Anne
Unknown Affiliation
van Erp, Theo G.M.
Unknown Affiliation
Van Den Heuvel, Odile A.
Unknown Affiliation
van der Meer, Dennis
Unknown Affiliation
Veer, Ilya Milos
Unknown Affiliation
Veltman, Dick J.
Unknown Affiliation
Venkatasubramanian, Ganesan
Unknown Affiliation
Vives-Gilabert, Yolanda
Unknown Affiliation
Voineskos, Aristotle N.
Unknown Affiliation
Völzke, Henry
Unknown Affiliation
Vuletic, Daniella
Unknown Affiliation
Walitza, Susanne
Unknown Affiliation
Walter, Henrik
Unknown Affiliation
Walton, Esther
Unknown Affiliation
Wardlaw, Joanna M.
Unknown Affiliation
Wen, Wei
Unknown Affiliation
Westlye, Lars T.
Unknown Affiliation
Whelan, Christopher D.
Unknown Affiliation
White, T. J.
Unknown Affiliation
Wiers, Reinout W.H.J.
Unknown Affiliation
Wright, Margaret J.
Unknown Affiliation
Wittfeld, Katharina
Unknown Affiliation
Yang, Tony T.
Unknown Affiliation
Yasuda, Clarissa Lin
Unknown Affiliation
Yücel, Murat
Unknown Affiliation
Yun, Je-yeon
Unknown Affiliation
Zanetti, M. V.
Unknown Affiliation
de Zubicaray, Greig I.
Unknown Affiliation
Zwiers, Marcel Peter
Unknown Affiliation
Glahn, David C.
Unknown Affiliation
Crivello, Fabrice
Unknown Affiliation
Fisher, Simon E.
Unknown Affiliation
Thompson, Paul M.
Unknown Affiliation
Flyckt, Lena Katarina
Unknown Affiliation
Engberg, Göran
Unknown Affiliation
Fatouros-Bergman, Helena
Unknown Affiliation
Červenka, Simon
Unknown Affiliation
Schwieler, Lilly
Unknown Affiliation
Piehl, Fredrik
Unknown Affiliation
Sellgren, Carl M.
Unknown Affiliation
Statistics
Citations: 8
Authors: 231
Affiliations: 3
Identifiers
Doi:
10.1002/hbm.25154
ISSN:
10659471