Lessons from a next generation carbon ranching experiment

Identifying grazing practices that maximize food production and soil carbon sequestration is of global importance. Currently, we cannot reliably predict which grazing practice will accrue the most soil organic carbon (SOC) partly because of confusion created by an abundance of low-quality experiments. Data quality has likely suffered because adequate treatment replication requires a lot of land, meaningful scale introduces heterogeneity among replicates, and pre-existing differences are often not taken into account. Here we tested the effects of five grazing treatments on SOC stocks with a gold standard randomized controlled trial (RCT) with pre-treatment data. Treatments were no grazing, severe summer grazing, moderate fall grazing, severe fall grazing, and the conventional approach for the system of moderate summer grazing. Because grazing experiments are often little-replicated, we also gauged the dependence of results on pre-treatment data by comparing the results of analyses with vs without pre-treatment data. We also tested for relationships between plant (root biomass, plant species composition) and soil properties (mass, nitrogen concentration) and SOC. After applying treatments for 5-yr, the no grazing and severe summer and fall grazing treatments accrued 0.85 to 1.22 kg × m−2 (0–60 cm soil depth) more SOC than conventional moderate summer grazing and represent appreciable (i.e. >4 per mille per yr) increases in SOC stocks. Furthermore, the entire portfolio of new grazing practices increased SOC accrual compared to conventional management. Given the divergent characteristics of the newly applied practices, sustainable accrual of SOC may depend on management heterogeneity. Accrual of SOC was likely driven by a reduction in SOC mineralization related to increased soil density and nitrogen, decreased root biomass, and change in plant species composition. Our findings counter the prevailing view that plant material inputs are the primary driver of SOC accrual in grazing lands. In other words, SOC accrual was mainly associated with indicators of decreased SOC mineralization (C outputs). We also found unique results for analyses with and without pre-treatment data, thereby indicating the risk of unreliable results for little-replicated RCTs without pre-treatment data. Robust generalizations on grazing practices that will reliably and sustainably maximize the rate of SOC accrual for a specific system, climate and timeline are still lacking, but further focus on factors affecting SOC mineralization will facilitate their development.